Bethany Eve has seen Madison Beer 2 times.

Madison Elle Beer (born March 5, 1999 in Jericho, New York) is a singer-songwriter who began her career as a teenager performing cover songs on YouTube. After attracting the attention of Justin Bieber who re-tweeted one of her covers, she gained global media coverage and signed with Bieber's Island Records. Her debut single "Melodies" dropped in 2013. Her debut EP "As She Pleases" was released in 2018 and included her first charting single "Home with You," which reached the top 100 in Norway and Ireland. In 2020, "Selfish" became Beer's first single to chart in the US, reaching 19 on the Hot 100. It was featured on her debut studio album "Life Support" (2021). Beer's second studio album "Silence Between Songs" dropped in 2023. The 2024 non-album single "Make You Mine" became her first top 10 hit in the US.